The author of this book, Sudeep Nagarkar, had earlier written Why Should I Trust You, which, like for many readers, had greatly impressed me as well. In that work, the narrative setting, the depth of the characters, and the subtle emotions of love were all beautifully crafted. Naturally, this created high expectations for this novel. However, it is my honest feeling that this book does not fully meet those expectations.

The story revolves around the lives of three young women staying in a college hostel. The author attempts to explore multiple emotions simultaneously—friendship, love, loneliness, and the search for identity. Though he is a male writer, his effort to present a feminine perspective is commendable.

However, whether this attempt succeeds completely depends on the reader’s mindset and social outlook. At the beginning of the story, the idea of “freedom” is emphasized through scenes where women drink and smoke, similar to men. While this may reflect a modern, realistic approach, it is uncertain whether all readers will accept it. At the very least, this novel is clearly suited for readers aged 16 and above.

The psychological states of individuals from the LGBTQ community, their internal struggles, and society’s perspective toward them are portrayed quite openly in the story. When read in English, these elements may feel fast-paced and natural. However, in a local or native-language reading context, certain portions may feel not just slightly—but significantly—uncomfortable.

It is not entirely clear which reader segment the author had in mind while writing this book. Compared to his previous novel, this one lacks the same emotional connection, the softness of romance, and the overall impact. Readers expecting a beautiful love story may feel disappointed. At best, this novel can be approached as a light read to pass two or three hours. However, it leaves behind very little lasting impression or a sense of having gained something meaningful after finishing it.